Protocol Comparison

Protocol Comparison
View more...
   EMBED

Share

Preview only show first 6 pages with water mark for full document please download

Transcript

Rajesh Sharma Serial No. Features Mod Bus A few(3) Application specific  data types NO NO NO Index(Common Addr:8,16) NO A few of same type & same  COT IEC‐60870‐5‐101 IEC‐60870‐5‐104 IEC‐60870‐5‐103 Some Application  Specific data NO NO Less Fixed Index(Common  Addr:8,16) YES A few of same type &  same COT NO Application Specific Information Model 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 A few(3) Application specific  A few(3) Application specific  data types data types NO NO NO Fixed Index(Common Addr:8,16) YES A few of same type & same  COT NO NO Open for additional models 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 Data Read Data Write Clock Sync Exchange Integrated totals Remote Substitutions(Online) Substitution Indication Time series data Sequence of Data Log & retrieve Selected data  value(Historical) at any time Parameter Settings control 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 GOOSE Sample Value Exchange(for CT & VT) Define Group of data Select data for reporting Enable/Disbale communication control  Object Change reporting/logging Behavior Load Configuration FEW NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO Single Single NO NO NO NO NO YES NO NO Single Single YES YES NO Quality Indication YES YES NO NO Single Single NO YES NO Quality Indication YES YES NO NO Single Single YES NO NO NO YES YES NO NO MANY MANY YES YES NO Quality Indication YES YES NO NO NO NO Fixed Index(Common Addr:8,16) YES A few of same type & same  COT NO DNP3 Permit US to  create  application  specific  extensions NO YES FULL Flexible Index(Common  Addr:8,16) YES Several of any  type Some IEC 61850  100 Logical nodes classes with 200+ data  classes Support Inheritance,Encapsulation. YES FULL Flexible Hierarchical Names YES Many of any type Data Name,Type,Function  characterstic,reporting,triggering Option  deadband etc ,for any data class defined &  accessible Flexible: any new Logical node.data &  Common data class can be defined for other  application area MANY MANY YES YES YES Quality Indication YES YES YES Object Oriented Modeling Data Object & Message Independent of  each other Common Application Layer/Encoding  Independent of data Defination Supported Data Type Address/Identification Time stamping >1 value in one message(Data  Groups,Data Sets) Self description of data (for online  retrieval) 9 FEW NO NO NO NO YES YES YES FEW NO NO NO NO YES YES YES Change some  ONLY predefined  Communication  Protection setting group related  Parameters NO NO NO NO NO YES NO YES NO NO NO YES YES YES Flexible(define change & edit) YES YES YES YES YES YES YES Location of Configuration 28 29 30 31 Automatic Verification of Online & Offline  configuration Data Model Independent of services Communication System Supported Configurationof RTU/Relay  database & application Configurationof RTU/Relay  database & application NO NO V.24/V.28 or X.24/X.27 Configurationof RTU/Relay  database & application NO NO TCP/IP over ethernet Configurationof  RTU/Relay database &  application NO NO RS‐485/Fiber Configurationof  The Complete configuration is in the Relay‐>  RTU/Relay  at any time consistent additionally in the  database &  XML file. application NO YES V.24/V.28 or  X.24/X.27 4 Layer(Serial) or  7 Layer TCP/IP or  UDP/IP Full Duplex IP Pseduo Transport  over  serial/TCP/IP NO YES YES V.24/V.28 or X.24/X.27 No NO RS‐485/Fiber/TCP/IP Layering 32 33 34 Mode Routing Transport protocol 35 36 37 38 39 Open for others Speed Redudancy Max Relays 3 Layer Un Balance NO NO NO MAX: NO 3 Layer Un Balance NO NO NO 7 Layer Balance IP TCP/IP over ethernet NO 3 Layer Unbalance NO NO NO NO 7 Layer TCP/IP Full Duplex IP ,OSI,NP TCP/IP,OSI TP YES YES